This is one of the most specific questions in the exam. The question wants you to design a programme, a strategy (which allows much freedom), but the program you propose must be based on the virus’ life cycle (therefore you MUST learn the rabies cycle). One question arises (and therefore adds to variability in exam answers): Is it even possible to eradicate a disease like rabies with current methods?
BACKGROUND (Textbook Schaechter, 2007, pp. 357-362)
Zoonosis caused by lyssavirus (RNA virus) from infected domesticated (dogs, cats) and wild animals (bats, raccons, jackals). Prevalent in many countries (50,000-100,000 deaths/year), more deaths common in developing countries (90%) where there is less programmes to combat disease. Virtually all people exhibiting symptoms will die (as they weren’t vaccinated), only few notable exceptions in recent times overruled this (see Wikipedia article HERE).
THE RABIES VIRUS LIFE CYCLE
Virus enters from the site of the bite, travelling in the peripheral nervous system (PNS) via nerves to CNS. It travels from the brain to peripheral sites (other organs) eliciting symptoms (virus retroactively travels back and forth brain and organs). Notably, salivary glands in mouth and cheeks will store high concentrations of the virus allowing transmissibility (especially if bitten). Incubation period varies from about 1 month to 3 months, but can be a year or more! (Depends on virulence strain-different locales or even point of infection-worse if face or neck).
SYMPTOMS
Important: Causes acute, progressive, incurable encephalitis (inflamm of the brain caused by infection/allergic reaction)- causes brain damage.
Acute progressive fever, headache, difficulty swallowing + hydrophobia (cannot swallow water to quench thirst), paresthesia (abnormal tingling, nerve damage), muscle spasms, hypersalivation (like rabid dogs), paralysis, mania (confusion, anxiety, etc)
PROGRAMMES
This programme has to tie in to YOUR UNDERSTANDING of the virus’ life cycle.
Methods have to be utilising already present strategies (ie. Cannot say.. we have to design a better vaccine that’s 100% effective before + after infection, that's not a program, that's a wish)
Vaccination of humans, wild and domesticated animals is most effective.
You may decide how far to take this: surely you can’t vaccinate every single living thing in the world, but maybe highly populated areas: suburbs, places of high prevalence. Or maybe people with high risk in contracting disease: kids, vet workers, gardeners, rangers, etc.
Surveillance/Animal control is key in human-populated areas. Ensure wild populations of bats are controlled (various methods to do that… ethically), but use of animal shelters/animal control rangers to isolate rabid stray dogs (euthanasing them, etc). Local leash laws to prevent pets becoming strays.
Education of the community. Advertising, schools-education, brochures to tell people to look for the symptoms (urgent intervention important), stay away from touching wild animals or strays (to prevent getting bitten)
POINTS TO CONSIDER NOW:
1. EACH OF THESE COMPONENTS NEED TO BE TIED BACK TO LIFE CYCLE (how it affects it)…
2. Ian Peak has put forth a rather ideological question, in how do you eradicate rabies as a human disease. My basis, if this were to be on the exam is that it is not possible to eradicate Rabies as a human disease with current methods. The only way is prevention, via vaccination, animal control and education to prevent infection (as you cannot feasibly enact a strategy to destroy all rabid animals, wild or domestic). In relating to stopping disease manifestation with a programme based on the virus life cycle, this is a difficult question. You will always have the possibility of infection as long as there are infected animals present. We can only control it to prevent infection in the first place, or find methods to fix the problem once infected (eg. the induced coma method as shown in Wikipedia).
3. Eventually, it culminates to the thought: What is eradication of a human disease. Strictly speaking, eradication is 'complete destruction', as in no chance of returning. However, this is not possible realistically (unless someone can tell me how), are we content to suggest eradication is like prevalence of Rabies in USA (about 1-3 cases a year, while 50,000-100,000 occur world-wide)...
Good Question, Ian. :S
If you have a differing opinion/additional info, write your own answer or comment below!
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
2 comments:
I think it's fair to say that to design an eradication program you'd need to go over quarantine and vaccination at
least.
Vaccines may be helpful in the prevention of spread and infection among the human population to say the least. They may also be employed in developing nations for their economy.
Vaccines DO exist however new candidates to improve them are currently being engineered;
- To this end an infectious human adenovirus type 5 recombinant virus that contains the rabies glycoprotein gene, and which may serve as the prototype for a new class of vaccines against rabies, see: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/2295855?ordinalpos=6&itool=EntrezSystem2.PEntrez.Pubmed.Pubmed_ResultsPanel.Pubmed_DefaultReportPanel.Pubmed_RVDocSum
Oral forms of vaccines available now... makes distribution more available among animal populations in the form of 'baiting'.
"successfully reduced rabies in rural areas of France, Ontario, Texas, Florida and elsewhere, like in the City of Montréal (Québec) where baits are successfully used among raccoons in the Mont-Royal park area" - Wikipedia (Rabies Article)
Early Reports by the WHO have established Rabies as a priority Zoonosis disease in many countries including China and Bangledesh.
- the culling of animals believed to be infected or serving as a reservoir of infection is observed in such countries.
- case reporting of animal bites, human deaths and animal deaths attributed to rabies has been established (e.g in china; since 1981-1982 till present).
- Vaccines administered among humans and animals (figures recorded)
see http://whqlibdoc.who.int/hq/1993/WHO_Rab.Res._93.44.pdf
sorry this is such a late addition to the blog-
however, on the CDC website (http://www.cdc.gov/rabies/about.html) there is a refernce to rabies as a 'human disease'. it states what boris and matt have aready said: that that the natural resivor is predominatly wild animal... for this reason it is not a 'disease of humans'. we are only incidental hosts.
i believe this will be one of the key points ian would like us to raise as the question proposes we design a program to eradicate rabies as a human disease.
Post a Comment